Strategic Planning and Board Retreats: How to Deal with a Bad Egg

Strategic Planning and Board Retreat: How to Deal with a Bad Egg
I've facilitated hundreds of nonprofit strategic planning sessions, and I've learned that the biggest obstacle to a productive discussion isn't always a lack of money, a weak strategy, or an uncertain future. Sometimes, it's sitting three chairs down from the CEO, armed with strong opinions, an impressive résumé, and absolutely no intention of listening.
Every board has its personalities. Most are thoughtful, dedicated people who genuinely want to help. But occasionally, one difficult board member can hijack an entire strategic planning session or board retreat, derail meaningful conversations, and leave everyone wondering why they sacrificed a perfectly good Saturday.
The best strategic planning sessions don't eliminate disagreement. They create an environment where everyone contributes, nobody dominates, and difficult personalities don't prevent good decisions. Here are five familiar characters I've encountered over the years—and how to manage them.
1. The Founder Who Still Thinks It's Their Organization
Founders are extraordinary people. They see possibilities others miss, take enormous risks, and build organizations from practically nothing. Unfortunately, some struggle to accept that the nonprofit has grown beyond their personal control.
I've watched founders challenge every new idea, defend outdated programs, and remind everyone how things were done 20 years ago. Their passion is admirable. Their inability to let go can be exhausting.
My approach: Honor their accomplishments without surrendering the conversation. Acknowledge the organization's history, then redirect toward its future. Ask, "What does this organization need to become over the next five years, even if that means doing things differently?" Respect the founder's legacy, but make it clear that legacy doesn't come with permanent veto power.
2. The Veteran Board Member Who Knows Everything
Every board seems to have one. She's served for 18 years, remembers every previous strategic plan, and can explain why virtually every new suggestion won't work. She's the unofficial organizational historian, parliamentarian, and occasional Supreme Court justice.
Institutional knowledge is valuable, but it becomes dangerous when experience turns into entitlement. I've seen newer board members stop contributing because they know their ideas will be immediately dismissed.
My approach: Establish ground rules that give everyone equal opportunity to speak. Use structured rounds, small-group discussions, and written exercises before opening the floor. Thank the veteran for her perspective, then invite others to challenge assumptions. Longevity deserves appreciation, not unlimited airtime.
3. The Enthusiastic New Board Member Who Won't Stop Talking
I love enthusiastic new board members. They bring energy, fresh perspectives, and a willingness to question sacred cows. Unfortunately, some haven't yet discovered the difference between contributing to a conversation and becoming the conversation.
They have an idea about everything. Every question triggers another story. Every suggestion requires a five-minute explanation. By lunchtime, everyone knows where they went to college, their previous employer's strategic plan, and possibly their dog's dietary restrictions.
My approach: Give discussions structure and establish speaking limits when necessary. I often ask participants to make their most important point in 60 seconds. It's remarkable how much sharper people become when they know the clock is running. Encourage enthusiasm, but make room for quieter voices.
4. The Negative Board Member Who Finds Fault with Everything
This person doesn't simply disagree. They specialize in making everyone else regret having an opinion. Every proposal is unrealistic, every opportunity is risky, and every new idea is greeted with the enthusiasm of a root canal.
Healthy skepticism is essential to good governance. But relentless negativity discourages participation and gradually poisons the room. I've watched entire discussions lose momentum because one person insists on explaining why nothing will work.
My approach: Don't argue with the negativity. Redirect it toward solutions. Ask, "What would need to change for this idea to succeed?" or "What alternative would you recommend?" Require constructive criticism rather than endless objections. And when behavior becomes disrespectful, address it directly. Civility isn't optional.
5. The Missing Board Member Who Suddenly Wants Control
This one is particularly entertaining. They miss half the meetings, rarely read board materials, and contribute little between gatherings. But the moment strategic planning begins, or a board retreat starts, they arrive with a commanding voice and a detailed list of what everyone else should be doing. Apparently, attendance is optional, but authority is not.
My approach: Establish expectations before the session. Share background materials, identify decisions that need to be made, and clarify how input will be considered. During discussions, ask participants to ground their recommendations in organizational facts and strategic priorities. Everyone deserves a voice, but nobody gets to rewrite six months of work simply because they finally showed up.
Takeaways
Set ground rules early. Establish expectations for respect, participation, and productive disagreement.
Control airtime. Use structured discussions to prevent dominant personalities from monopolizing conversations.
Honor experience without granting veto power. Institutional knowledge should inform strategy, not imprison it.
Turn criticism into solutions. Require constructive alternatives, not endless objections.
Protect quieter voices. Some of the best ideas come from people who don't fight for attention.
Use an independent facilitator. Skilled facilitation helps manage difficult dynamics without placing the CEO in the referee's chair.
Final Thoughts
After years of facilitating nonprofit strategic planning sessions, I've learned that difficult personalities don't necessarily ruin a planning session or retreat. Allowing them to dominate does. Strong facilitation requires preparation, diplomacy, humor, and occasionally the courage to interrupt someone who has mistaken a productive day for their personal TED Talk.
The best strategic planning sessions and board retreats aren't about keeping everyone happy. They're about creating honest conversations, making thoughtful decisions, and building a shared commitment to the organization's future.
One bad egg shouldn't spoil the process. But somebody needs to be willing to crack down. :-)
Tom Iselin
Rated One of America’s Best Board Retreat
and Strategic Planning Facilitators
About the Author
Tom Iselin is recognized as one of America’s leading authorities on high-performance nonprofits. He has built nine sector-leading nonprofits and two software companies, written six books, sits on multiple boards, and has been rated one of America’s Best Board Retreat and Strategic Planning Facilitators. His work on nonprofit strategy, board leadership, and culture has been featured on CNN, Nightline, and in Newsweek.
Tom is the president of First Things First, a firm specializing in board retreats, strategic planning services, fundraising strategy, and executive coaching for nonprofit CEOs.
Board Retreats & Strategic Planning
If you’re looking for a board retreat facilitator or strategic planning facilitator who has been in the trenches and understands real-world nonprofit challenges, Tom can help your board gain clarity, build alignment, and create an actionable plan that improves performance and impact. His sessions propel organizations to the next level of performance and impact . . . and they're fun!
Board Retreats and Strategic Planning Services:
858.888.2278


























